Colosseum Discussion 3 (QFs and Beyond)

[Thaal Sinestro]

Different round, different grade! I keep telling people not to compare rounds xD

IT ONLY LEADS TO SUFFERING.

shouldn't the grades only really be incomparable via the judge changing, not the round? otherwise consistency gets to be questionable.

We strive for consistency, but it's just not gonna work out like that, you know? The grades work best on a fight-by-fight basis as a comparison of two writers to the best ability of the one person judging, at that exact time. There's just no way to ensure that it's consistent from fight to fight, even though we all try really hard to keep it that way.