G-Dog vs Ear Man

[Ganondorf]

Who do YOU think won the fight? Let us know here! Just click the guy in the poll who you think did a better job. You don't even have to give a reason, though it's much appreciated if you do.

I'll go first. Enel likely won. I missed one deadline and got extended twice. Additionally, I think his posts flowed better and he had less grammar and spelling mistakes.

[Schwi Dola]

If extending the deadline is itself bad my vote doesn't count, and I haven't read anything yet. I would consider this a fundamental flaw with evaluation.

Also a community vote is probably unfair pressure on the judge, especially if the judge feels that the majority is wrong

[Ganondorf]

It was in my own evaluation of myself. You're free to use whatever guidelines you want. But I felt that if I picked a fight with Enel, then I should at least stick by the guidelines I set for it.

[Ganondorf]

Me and Omni agreed on Link and to abide by his decision. Doesn't matter if he's the only one who thinks it. I'll stand by it.

[Omni]

If extending the deadline is itself bad my vote doesn't count, and I haven't read anything yet. I would consider this a fundamental flaw with evaluation.

Also a community vote is probably unfair pressure on the judge, especially if the judge feels that the majority is wrong

I agree with this.

[Ganondorf]

I'll go ahead and lock this then.